Get $35 off when you sign up for new service.
Customer Portal

Brown Widows vs. Black Widows in Montana: What’s the Difference

Black Widow Spider

Most Montanans are familiar with the Northern black widow spider—especially folks who’ve stumbled into their cobwebs under a deck or near the shed. But lately, brown widow spiders have been making their way into conversations, too.

And for good reason: they’re not just a color variation. These two widow species are close cousins, but they come with some important differences.

Here’s how to tell which widow you’re dealing with and what to do about it if one turns up around your home.

Key Takeaways

  • Black widows are common in Montana while brown widows are rare but may show up during warmer years.
  • Brown widow venom is less toxic than black widow venom but it can still cause discomfort if you get bitten.
  • Widow spiders hide in garages, basements, and crevices so sealing those areas helps stop an infestation early.
  • Pest control helps remove spiders and egg sacs while protecting your home from future problems in hard-to-reach places.

Black Widow vs. Brown Widow: Quick Comparison

The Bug Files

Black widow or brown widow? On file

Two widow cousins, two different rap sheets. Both carry venom, but one packs a far more potent bite. Here is how to tell them apart.

2 suspects1 armed1 harmless
CASE 01VENOMOUS

Black Widow

Western black widow

The TellShiny black body with a bright red hourglass underneath.
HauntGarages, basements, woodpiles, and fence lines.
M.O.The female’s more potent neurotoxin bite can be painful and sometimes need medical attention.
CASE 02LESS POTENT

Brown Widow

Brown widow spider

The TellDark brown to tan with an orange to yellow hourglass.
HauntSheltered corners, garages, and landscaping.
M.O.Venom is less toxic than the black widow’s, but a bite can still cause pain and nausea.
Snap a photo from a distance and let a Kodiak pro confirm the ID, then Kodiak logs it in your Bug Files report.
black vs brown widow comparison

You don’t need an entomology degree to tell the brown and black widow spiders apart, but knowing these differences can help you figure out what’s hanging out in your garage or under the deck.

Features Black Widow Brown Widow
Color Shiny black with a red hourglass Dark brown to tan, sometimes gray
Hourglass Marking Bright red hourglass on the underside of the abdomen Orange to yellow hourglass marking
Common in Montana? Yes – western black widow spider is widespread Rare but showing up more, especially in warmer years
Native Range Widespread in North America Native to South Africa and South America; now in Florida, and Southern California

What to Do If You Spot One Around Your Home

If you think you’ve found a widow spider near your home, you don’t need to panic—but you do want to be smart about it.

Here’s how we recommend handling things if one turns up on your property:

Identify It Before Acting

Both the southern black widow and western black widow are found across the U.S., but in Montana, it’s most likely the western species. Female black widows are the ones to watch for—the adult female has a more potent bite and that signature red mark underneath. Male black widows are much smaller and not considered dangerous.

Female brown widow spiders are easier to misidentify since they blend in with other house spiders or even Steatoda (false widows).

The best approach?

Snap a picture (from a safe distance) and call in pest control if you’re unsure. Local pros trained in pest management and entomology can ID it for you.

Don’t Swat or Smash

A widow spider bite usually happens when someone surprises or crushes one accidentally. These arachnids aren’t aggressive by nature.

That said, black widow bites can be painful due to the potency of their neurotoxin, and sometimes serious enough to need medical attention.

Bites from brown widow spiders aren’t as dangerous, but their toxicity can still cause pain, nausea, and discomfort according to poison control reports.

Best move? Back away and let a pro handle it

Check for Egg Sacs and Spiderlings

One adult female can lay dozens of egg sacs, each releasing hundreds of spiderlings. A single unnoticed infestation can get out of hand fast.

Keep an eye out in garages, basements, and sheltered corners of your property. Look under furniture and inside voids, especially around landscaping, woodpiles, and fence lines.

Seal Up Entry Points

Widows love quiet crevices, gaps in siding, and dark corners near warmth. Patch those up when you find them, especially around foundations and under eaves.

This won’t just help with spiders—it’ll help with all kinds of pests trying to sneak in.

Schedule Preventative Pest Control

Widows are just one species of spiders we deal with here in the Big Horn Basin and Billings. Our standard pest management plan includes control of widow species, brown recluse (which is not naturally found in Montana, by the way), wolf spiders, and others.

At Kodiak Pest Control, we don’t just spray the perimeter and call it good. We treat crevices, fence lines, garages, woodpiles, and outdoor living spaces.

That’s how we keep black widows from showing up in your boots and brown widow bites off your backyard to-do list.

Need help with spiders or want to stay ahead of an infestation?

Give us a shout. We’re proud to be the go-to pest control team for homeowners across Wyoming and southern Montana.

🤓 Author

Smiling man wearing Kodiak Pest & Lawn jacket and cap, indoors with a blurred wooden wall behind him

🤓 Author

Jacob Haslem
Founder, Owner, Kodiak Pest Control
This article was written by an expert with over 17 years of experience in the industry.

Table of contents

Limited Time Offer

Save $35 on your 1st service

❤️ You’re supporting a small local business
Current response time ~10 minutes during business hours
🗓️ Limited Time Offer

Save $35 on your first pest control service

24 years of combined experience
Pest-free guarantee
Family owned business
Smiling man wearing Kodiak Pest Control jacket and cap with an American flag patch in an office setting
Jacob Haslem
17 years of pest control experience
Founder and Owner of Kodiak Pest Control
Lifelong resident of the Mountain West US area
Jacob Haslem, a lifelong resident of the Big Horn Basin, is the founder and driving force behind Kodiak Pest Control. With over 17 years of industry experience, including running a successful pest control business in Utah. Jacob brings a wealth of expertise to his work in Wyoming. Raised with a strong work ethic, Jacob is committed to delivering flawless results for every customer. He pairs his technical know-how with a personal touch, treating each property as if it were his own.